Jonathan Ross/iStock by way of Getty Photographs
Maui Land & Pineapple (NYSE:MLP) is a Hawaiian actual property firm. The corporate started in 1909 as an agricultural operation rising pineapples. It bought most of its land within the early 1900s. In more moderen years, nevertheless, agriculture has change into much less value aggressive in Hawaii as in comparison with different tropical areas. As such, Maui Land & Pineapple has transitioned from being an agriculture firm to primarily being a resort operator and land growth firm.
I discover land financial institution shares attention-grabbing. They provide a singular type of funding, giving buyers inflation safety whereas probably giving important proper tail upside if the land in query experiences a catalyst which might rework its valuation. For instance, Texas Pacific Land (TPL) shares loved a parabolic run-up over the previous decade as its rural Texan land grew to become dramatically extra priceless because of the fracking increase.
Maui Land & Pineapple, against this, has not managed to take pleasure in any such laborious catalyst in latest instances. Shares exploded increased in 2017 amid a flurry of articles and dialogue in regards to the firm within the worth investing group. Since then, nevertheless, MLP inventory has given up these features and largely traded sideways. Shares have dipped a bit bit extra in latest months, and are actually close to a 5-year low in value:
As such, it is time to revisit Maui Land & Pineapple. In any case, these kinds of land performs are typically dormant for prolonged durations of time after which all of a sudden spring to life when new initiatives emerge, activists take a place, or different such catalysts emerge. The time to go trying to find these kinds of firms tends to be throughout these prolonged dormant durations earlier than they begin making headlines once more.
What Maui Land & Pineapple Owns
These days, the agency primarily operates as an actual property firm and land financial institution. It operates the Kapalua Resort and membership. It additionally seeks to develop and revenue from its actual property holdings, together with working leasing operations for its present properties.
As of Dec. 31, 2021, right here is the land that Maui Land & Pineapple owns:
MLP’s land holdings (10-Okay)
As you may see, nearly all of the corporate’s land holdings are in West Maui, with the steadiness in Upcountry Maui.
On paper, the corporate owns 22,800 acres in complete. Nevertheless, 9,000 of that is unavailable for growth because of being conservation or watershed land. As well as, one other 12,900 acres are at the moment zoned for agriculture. Given Hawaii’s growth practices, it might take a very long time, if ever, for a lot of this land to be transformed to higher-value usages.
That leaves the corporate with its crown jewels, the 900 acres of totally entitled city land. These 900 acres are on the Kapalua Resort, the place the corporate already has the correct zoning in locations and plans to additional develop this property between immediately and 2039. Given the gradual tempo of deliberate growth, it should not have an excessive amount of hassle arising with funding for pushing this venture ahead.
This land must be exceptionally priceless. Hawaii has among the many most restrictive development laws within the nation, and Maui County particularly has rigorous requirements even compared to the remainder of Hawaii. In Hawaii, the median single household dwelling value is roughly two and a half instances the nationwide common. Provided that Maul Land & Pineapple can promote heaps subsequent to its present resort amenities, this could assist energy even increased land values. Primarily based on prior comparable transactions within the space up to now, it isn’t laborious to think about this land being value a number of hundred thousand {dollars} an acre if developed correctly and bought in a strategic method.
Ongoing Outcomes Close to Break-Even
Maui Land & Pineapple does have some ongoing operations, primarily within the type of its resort and related leasing actions.
The corporate’s outcomes are fairly variable from year-to-year, with important variation because of financial exercise and one-off offers and alternatives. I would observe that the corporate’s web earnings has typically been proper round zero, and it wasn’t considerably worthwhile on an operations foundation even previous to the onset of COVID-19:
The corporate did generate greater than $5 million in web earnings over the previous yr, which is a significant enchancment from previous outcomes. Regardless, given the comparatively small quantity of earnings and the numerous variability of it, I would not assign an excessive amount of worth to the day-to-day operations of the corporate. The true worth is within the underlying land.
An Underfollowed & Off-The-Radar Inventory
Maui Land & Pineapple will not be a broadly adopted firm. It has minimal analyst protection, little retail investor consideration, and never a lot in the best way of common buying and selling quantity both. As well as, administration does little to market or shine mild on the enterprise.
Talking up to now, that is the whole lot of the corporate’s investor relations internet web page:
MLP’s Investor Relations website (Company web site)
There isn’t any investor presentation or any type of flashy details about the corporate. Just a few .pdfs of routine paperwork, together with hyperlinks to SEC filings. This lack of any give attention to advertising and marketing the corporate may result in a decrease valuation, in comparison with different companies within the business.
In principle, this must be interesting for worth buyers, who care extra in regards to the underlying property than and glitz and glamor across the funding. Nevertheless, except the corporate takes concrete steps to start out getting its story extra publicity, there isn’t a cause to imagine this valuation hole will shut anytime quickly.
Some firms with a low profile are extremely savvy, like Berkshire Hathaway (BRK.A) (BRK.B) which is understood for its low-tech web site.
That stated, Maui Land & Pineapple’s administration has not essentially earned this identical degree of belief. The corporate’s steadiness sheet administration, traditionally, has left loads to be desired. For instance, the agency was carrying near $100 million of debt, together with $60 million of short-term debt, in the course of the 2008 monetary disaster. The mix of this massive debt with an absence of money or significant revenues led to the agency having a liquidity scarcity and having to concern shares at depressed costs. MLP inventory plunged from $30 to $5 in the course of the disaster and has largely did not recuperate subsequently.
For an additional instance, Maui Land & Pineapple ended up having $40 million of debt come due at one level in 2016. The corporate was capable of navigate that maturity extra efficiently, nevertheless, in numerous financial circumstances, that might have probably impaired shareholder worth as effectively.
Lastly, I would observe that insiders personal 65% of the corporate’s excellent inventory. This may very well be an impediment to exterior shareholders who search to maximise complete worth of the corporate’s property, relying on how insiders resolve to handle and develop the assorted land holdings on the firm.
MLP Inventory Backside Line
Maui Land & Pineapple at the moment has a market cap of about $180 million. There’s not a lot occurring with the steadiness sheet to impression that quantity both. The corporate held $11 million in money as of final report, and has minimal long-term liabilities. So, buyers are paying round $175 million or so in complete worth for the corporate’s land and operations.
I imagine the operations aren’t value all that a lot, as they have an inclination to interrupt even or generate a minimal revenue on an annual foundation. That stated, it is sufficient to cowl the corporate’s working prices and thus forestall the corporate from having to promote land or dilute shareholders to maintain functioning. So there may be some worth from that. Nevertheless, many of the valuation right here comes from future land gross sales.
Valuing the 900 acres of prime zoned land at $300,000 an acre would give us $270 million of future valuation. Worth the agricultural land at $10k/acre and that is one other $129 million, or $399 million in complete. I’ve seen some bulls worth the agricultural land at excess of this determine. And which may be potential. Actually, small parcels of agricultural land on Maui promote for excess of $10,000/acre. Nevertheless, I am undecided what kind of value the corporate would receive if it tried to maneuver giant chunks of agricultural land in a single transaction.
There’s additionally the proposed Hali’imaile City plan. That is removed from sure, however there may be some chance on the Hali’imaile City venture getting favorable zoning, and that may rework 300 acres from a comparatively low valuation into one thing value tons of of hundreds of {dollars} an acre. Be it from Hali’imaile City, basic inflation in asset costs, or another catalyst that may monetize present worth, I believe you may fairly get to a $400-$500 million vary for honest worth for the corporate’s property.
Does this make the inventory a pound-the-table purchase at immediately’s $175 million valuation? No, not likely. That is due to the time worth of cash, together with execution threat.
The corporate is planning to develop the important thing 900 acres of land between now and 2039 in accordance with the corporate’s 10-Okay. Moreover, Hali’imaile City, if it turns into a actuality, is more likely to be developed within the 2030s. Buyers ought to low cost income from these future land gross sales dramatically provided that it may very well be a decade or extra between now and when Maui Land & Pineapple will get its money from a lot of those gross sales.
As well as, there may be uncertainty round what Steve Case and different insiders need to do with the corporate. Assuming Maui Land & Pineapple does generate windfall money from property growth, would the corporate begin to return important money to shareholders, or would these funds stay sitting on the corporate’s steadiness sheet?
I believe you can also make a reasonably compelling low cost to web asset worth calculation argument for MLP inventory immediately. As such, I view shares as a purchase if you need publicity to Hawaii and this type of land financial institution/name choice on growth asset. That stated, significantly with a slowing housing market and unfavorable rate of interest setting, I see little catalyst for shares to carry out in 2023. Nevertheless, with the inventory close to 5-year lows, this looks as if a tremendous entry level for folk that need to sit on shares for some time.